Former principal, now board member, talks about closing the school she used to lead

Yesterday, I called York City School Board member Jane Hines to get her thoughts on the votes made Wednesday to close Hannah Penn and Edgar Fahs Smith middle schools and move the elementary schools to a kindergarten – eighth grade structure.

Jane Hines (submitted photo)

Why did I call Hines? Prior to becoming a school board member, Hines had been principal at Smith Middle School. She retired in 2011.

I thought that gave her a particularly unique perspective on the move.

“It was an emotional time for me because I spent the majority of my adult career at Smith Middle School,” Hines said.  She had previously taught math there, as well.

Hines voted in favor of closing Smith and Hannah Penn and in favor of moving to the K-8 structure.

Decisions have to be made based on what’s best for all children, she said, and she thinks the move to K-8 will be a good one.

“I think that having the community, the students going to community schools is going to be good for a lot of reasons,” Hines said.

The schools will have smaller numbers of seventh- and eighth-graders instead of large concentrations, she said. The middle schools often had difficulties with some behavior issues.

Having students return to their home elementary schools and to those elementary teachers who influenced them at early age will be “extremely beneficial for them,” she said.

“I think this is going to be a positive for everyone,” Hines said.

About Angie Mason

I'm the education reporter at the York Daily Record/Sunday News. I want to know what's happening inside York County classrooms. Email me at or follow me on Twitter: @angiemason1
This entry was posted in Angie Mason, Elementary school, Middle school, York City School District and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Former principal, now board member, talks about closing the school she used to lead

  1. Jo Ott says:

    It truly is a sad time for all of us who ever attended Edgar Fahs Smith as I did from 1947 thru 1950. Of that great York High class of 1954 (about 600) many went thru EFS, some attended Phineas Davis middle school and others, Hannah Penn. When we have reunions or the classmates who have lunch together every month there is often joking about those present who went to Smith or “Oh, you went to Davis.” We Smith kids always felt far superior to Davis & Hannah Penn kids. It was always in jest, of course, and given the size of that York High class lifetime friendships were made and, as Brittany Wilson discovered when she visited the lunch group a few weeks ago, we are a jovial bunch who enjoy each other’s company.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *