I’m sorry, Aunt Lilly

I’m sorry for calling you a killer all of these years.

I was writing a story recently about the murder arraignment of a woman accused of  fatally dosing her grandmother’s chili with morphine to cover the fact, police say, she had been stealing money from the old woman’s bank accounts.

A childhood memory triggered. For years, I have repeated the family lore that my great aunt had attempted to kill her husband with poison pancakes.

This was in 1936, 1937 or thereabouts in Liverpool, Ill., on the western bank of the Illinois River, north of the mouth of Spoon River.

My mother would have been around 4 years old.

As the story went, Aunt Lilly wanted to kill her husband so she could run off with her lover.

Except her husband didn’t eat the pancakes.  Instead, her boyfriend came over after Lilly’s husband went to work – and Lilly was elsewhere – and ate the pancakes. The story went that Lilly’s son also ate the pancakes.  Both died.

Nobody could tell me what happened to Lilly.

So, I wrote the story about the alleged drugged chili murder, went home and called my folks.

Their recollection of the poison pancake murders was pretty much the same as mine.

The story was strange enough I thought I should be able to find it in historical records. I looked online and found nothing.

Continue reading

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

How to look up bad guys, that creepy neighbor or your daughter’s new boyfriend.

For years, I have a provided a free service to family, friends and co-workers running criminal background checks.

It’s about time you all learn to do it by yourselves.

It’s not that difficult.

Get on your computer, iPad, SmartPhone or whatever device you use to connect to the internet.

Go to ujsportal.pacourts.us.

In the gold box below and to the left of the scary-looking building, click on “Docket Sheets.” In the drop-down box that appears, click on “Common Pleas Courts.”

Scroll down to the “Search Type:” box. In that drop-down box, select “Participant Name.”

In the new window, you only need to type in the last name, the first name and the county to see if the person you are looking for has any criminal charges here.

The other window boxes, such as “Date of Birth,” will help you narrow your search.

In the bottom block of boxes under “and any combination of” you must enter either a county or in the “Docket Type” box, “criminal,” “miscellaneous” or “summary appeal.” I’ll bet “criminal” is what you’re looking for. Leave the county line blank and you will get a state-wide search.

All you really need to know if the first few letters of the first and last name.

Click “Search.”

If your gut feelings are misguided, the response you will get is “No results found.”

If your suspicions are correct, a line or a list may come up.

If it does, place your cursor over the box on the left side. A small window will appear with the words “Docket Sheet” and “Court Summary.”

Click on “Docket Sheet” and the case should come up. The information contains no criminal complaints or affidavits. But it can tell you if someone has a criminal record.

If you have problems, get back to me.

Next time I’ll take a shot at deciphering those docket sheets.

Posted in Criminal court | 1 Comment

Killer accuses DA of jury intimidation

Convicted of third-degree murder and sentenced to 20 to 40 years, Shannon Mayo Jr. now is claiming the York County District Attorney’s Office intimidated his jury.

A handful of jurors had told Judge John S. Kennedy that two men, who they recognized from the courtroom, had followed them to a parking garage after the trial recessed during deliberations. One juror said he was followed as he drove home. Two others said they received hang-up calls that night.

York County detectives investigated the possibility of attempted jury intimidation. It was determined that the two men were supporters of Mayo but were not attempting to intimidate the jurors and any contact with them was incidental.

In his latest motion – again without going through his attorney – Mayo claims, “someone in the District Attorney’s Office made those phone calls and followed Juror #11.”

Mayo called the investigation a “sham,” and added, “This is a homicide case. A man lost his life and the defendant’s (sic) received what amounts to a life or death sentence.”

When sentencing Mayo, Kennedy said his voluminous pro se correspondence, “general demeanor and persona” led him to question Mayo’s stability.

Mayo’s motion was docketed in court and forwarded to his attorney. Mayo is awaiting a post-sentence hearing on the motions filed by his attorney, which do not include accusing the prosecution of jury intimidation.

Mayo also mailed a copy of his motion to “The Court Reporter,” in care of the judicial center. No one else seemed to fit that description so it ended up in my hands.

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

It’s a nice drive to Brogue (I get paid mileage)

Police Chief Tom Gross has voiced his displeasure that District Justice John Fishel’s courtroom could be moved to Brogue.

At the York Area Regional Police Commission meeting Jan. 12, Gross commented that people in Dallastown and Red Lion may have to take the scenic drive through the countryside to Chanceford Township instead of the quick trip to Cape Horn Road just north of Red Lion.

As for crime victims, Gross said, “They’ve already been victimized once. Why victimize them again by making them drive to Brogue?”

Attention residents of Brogue: The chief was laughing when he said that and explained he was concerned about transportation costs and travel time. I am sure he has nothing against the town of Brogue or its residents.

According to the York County Office of Court Administration, a move by Fishel to Brogue would be temporary and only because of an existing rental lease on the Brogue office.

Posted in Civil court, Criminal court | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

An OMG moment for courthouse deputies

You would think the deputies working the lobby security detail at the York County Judicial Center — manning the metal detector and repeating their mantra, “No we can’t hold your cellphone, you have to take it out of the building” — have seen it all.

Recently, they were treated, or subjected, to something completely different.

An elderly man’s metal hip replacement, of course, set off the metal detector.

Instead of complying with a deputy’s directive to stand on the red X to get wanded, the man instead immediately dropped his pants to show his surgical scar.

Posted in Civil court, Criminal court | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Who’s the sharp-dressed man?

I don’t want to pick a fight with local used car salesmen. My 1999 Ford Ranger is closing in on 100,000 miles and I don’t want to go truck shopping incognito.

But I thought anyone willing to go into used car sales in the first place would have skin as thick as say, a news reporter.

Just last month while covering a potential story, a woman in her Sunday finest standing on church house steps glared at me and told me, “Go back where you came from.”

A lot of things I’ve been called over the years — usually by criminal defendants’ mothers, wives and girlfriends and the occasional attorney — aren’t printable. Continue reading

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Defense attorney Floyd P. Jones died Dec. 21

He often looked like he slept in the suit he came to court in.

His tie, usually hanging out of a pocket before trial, appeared to be an afterthought.

The comb-over didn’t add anything toward a professional appearance.

But under the used car salesman persona was a sharp defense attorney.

Floyd P. Jones, a regular in the York County courthouse until 2003, died Dec. 21 at Hershey Medical Center. He was 62.
floyd jones
When he was in his prime, any jury trial involving Jones was bound to be entertaining, at least from the perspective of a news reporter.

His cross-examination of prosecution witnesses could be brutal, especially when he challenged an expert witness’s findings and commonwealth witnesses with less than stellar backgrounds who were subpoenaed into court.

“He was a good lawyer,” former assistant district attorney Bill Graff said Monday. “I never underestimated him.”

Graff and Jones faced off repeatedly over the years in cases before Sr. Judge John H. Chronister. Jones frequently represented low-level drug dealers and Chronister regularly appointed him to defend indigent homicide suspects.

“He looked disorganized and disheveled, but he knew what he was doing,” Graff said. “He was a worthy adversary.”

Jones spent some time in the DA’s office and also in the public defender’s office working with Chronister, Richard Renn who also was elected judge, and Tom Kearney, now the county’s DA. Chronister said Jones was of “equal caliber and ability” with the others.

Chronister recalled his observation that it was best not to get Jones’ passions up in the courtroom. When someone did, Jones “became better,” Chronister said.

“He would become so aroused in his passion he could convince you, just because he believed so strongly, it had to be true,” Chronister said.

Chronister said Jones’ was not big on drawing attention to himself and that his primary interest for his clients was “to get the right result. Justice, so to speak, unlike many attorneys. He wanted a fair result.”

Jones’s life and law career fell apart in the early 2000s. Those close to him may know why. I don’t.

Jones disappeared from York County in late 2003 after failing to appear at a domestic relations hearing over outstanding spousal support.

He was disbarred in March 2005 for abandoning his law practice and failing to complete work a client had paid him for.

He remained a fugitive until June 26, 2005, when he was arrested on a York County warrant in Harpers Ferry, W.Va.

Jones appeared in the court where he had practiced in August 2005 — wearing an orange prison jumpsuit and handcuffs — and pleaded guilty to taking $2,236 of a client’s money and no contest to passing 14 bad checks.

He was sentenced to time served – 28 days – to 23 months.

“I was always surprised that he got into difficulties later because he was such a good attorney,” Chronister said.

Jones’ funeral is 5 p.m. Dec. 30 at Foursquare Gospel Church, 518 Wilson Ave., Hanover.

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Live coverage from court

Each day, Rick Lee gives live updates on York County’s criminal and civil court systems in the Cover It Live below, where you can also share your questions and comments for Rick.

Posted in Civil court, Criminal court | Leave a comment

Why Sandusky is entitled to bail

Following former Penn State coach Jerry Sandusky’s latest arrest on more sexual child abuse charges, I was being asked, “Why don’t they just keep him in jail?”

Chief Deputy Prosecutor Jenn Russell, of the York County District Attorney’s Office, has the answer.

She said, with the exception for murder, “people are entitled to some form of bail.”

There is typically no bail for murder defendants in Pennsylvania because of the serious penalties the charges carry — life without parole or a death sentence for a  first-degree murder conviction, life without parole for second-degree and 20 to 40 years in state prison for third-degree.

All other state level charges may be, depending on the circumstances, bailable offenses, she said.

Sandusky was freed on $100,000 unsecured bail following his first arrest. That means, he did not actually have to post any bail. Bail for his second arrest was set at $250,000. Sandusky put up his house for $200,000 of that and a $50,000 bond for the remainder.

“Bail is to insure that a defendant will appear for court,” Russell said. “It is not to be in itself a form of punishment.”

“Every place is different as to what it high bail,” she said. “It’s supposed to be a reasonable amount. But it’s up to the judges as to what that amount is.”

She said judges consider such factors as any prior criminal history, family connections to the area and whether the person may be a flight risk.

“The court looks at a defendant as someone who has been accused, not convicted, and entitled to due process,” Russell said. ”Bail is part of that due process.”

As for Sandusky already on the hook for $350,000 for his freedom pending trial, Russell said his options may be limited if any additional charges are filed. She said his assets likely are limited and a bondsman may not want to take a chance on him.

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Child sex abuse victims have until age 50 to file a complaint

I had to reach out to current and former child abuse prosecutors to decipher the commonwealth’s statute of limitations on sexual offenses committed against minors.

They agreed that the current law, most recently amended in 2008, gives the commonwealth authority in most cases to prosecute a child abuser up until the victim turns 50.

That’s for a dozen specific child abuse crimes ranging from rape to indecent exposure committed after July 2006 when the law was amended to extend the statute of limitations.

The law governing the limitations statute for sex offenses has been amended six times since 1984. 

The subsection of the statute I was interested in states: “Any sexual offense committed against a minor who is less than 18 years of age any time up to the later of the period of limitation provided by the law after the minor has reached 18 years of age or the date the minor reaches 50 years of age.”

That is what sent me searching for experienced child abuse prosecutors.

Attorney Christopher Moore, the former child abuse prosecutor, explained the ’06 amendment basically states that a victim under the age of 18 at the time of the offense — post-2006 — has until age 50 to file a complaint.

Special victims prosecutor Amy Eyster also explained that when prosecuting sexual offenses that occurred before the 2006 amendment, the commonwealth must apply the law that was in effect at the time of the offense.

For adult victims of sexual crimes, the statute of limitations to bring prosecution is 12 years from the date of the offense.

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment