Tag Archives: Carbaugh brothers dismemberment

Verdict spin?

Steve Rice, attorney for Justin Carbaugh, is taking exception to the York County District Attorney’s website claiming an apparent victory in the Carbaugh case. Carbaugh was convicted in October of voluntary manslaughter and abuse of a corpse after eight hours … Continue reading

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Justin Carbaugh’s attorney: ‘It was a crime of passion’

4:30 p.m.: The jury in the Carbaugh trial has asked to be dismissed for the day. Judge John S. Kennedy has granted that request. The jury — seven women and five men — will return at 9 a.m. Friday. 2:20 … Continue reading

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Justin Carbaugh testifies about shooting, dismembering his brother

3:56 p.m.: Both sides have rested. Closing arguments are set for Thursday morning. 3:17 p.m.: The defense has rested. The prosecution is calling rebuttal witnesses. 3:05 p.m.: Expert witnesses testified blood found on Brandon’s gun was his. The defense called … Continue reading

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged | 4 Comments

Jury sees, hears gruesome testimony in murder-dismemberment case

4:30 p.m.: Jessica Henderson, Brandon Carbaugh’s longtime girlfriend, testified that he spent the day before he was killed “snorting drugs … pain pills.” “He was fine that day because he had the drugs,” she said. She said Brandon also could … Continue reading

Posted in Criminal court | Tagged | Leave a comment