York Town Square · Green Mesh · Argento's Front Stoop · The Lineup Card · FlipSide Blog · more blogs ...

Ethanol reality day

In honor of local resident Ray Wallace, who dedicates part of his life filling the greenmesh email inbox with reasons why corn based ethanol production is a mistake in the US., I dedicate today as Ethanol reality day.

Why this alternative fuel has gained so much momentum in production is a formulation of political incentives and feeding an existing ethanol (read commodities and entrenched profit models) infrastructure. The reality is that there seems to be not much good for the general public not to mention the overall environmental impact and benefit as an alternative fuel.

"There's a low level of interest in E85, a low level of understanding," Louis Sheetz, the Altoona-based company's executive vice president of marketing, said Tuesday at a forum on the fuel at Carnegie Mellon University. "It will be a gradual learning experience for consumers."

More than a year after Sheetz gas stations and stores in Monroeville, Pleasant Hills and Robinson switched diesel pumps over to the blend, each of the three locations is selling less than half the volume that those pumps turned out before they were converted to E85.

Sheetz and representatives of General Motors Corp., the state Department of Environmental Protection and Steel City Biofuels took part in the program hosted by the university's Green Design Institute, in order to talk up E85. pittsburghlive.com

I try to find something good about corn to ethanol production. The consequences of the execution of the production of this fuel will eventually sour the American public to the concept of biofuels at a time when marketing acceptance of biofuels in general is more important then the fuel itself.

Ray, take it from here in the comment link... you are better at this than me.

It's true that ethanol can lower greenhouse emissions at the tailpipe and reduce the use of foreign oil, at the consumer level, but the price of production is so high it hardly warrants the execution of the product.

Corn is a food based raw material, fluctuations in crop yield because it is tied to energy infrastructure will ultimately cause threaten the price of food. (greenmesh 7/17)

Corn takes huge quantities of water over other crops. The push to produce more ethanol could threaten already dwindling water supplies, according to National Research Council report released October 10.

Ethanol is too corrosive to transport in pipe, unlike gasoline and natural gas it needs trucks burning fuel to bring to market from far away places like North Dakota.

Previous greenmesh posts on Ethanol

Ethanol refineries are sprouting up in communities at the point of the raw resource, adding pollution, and risks.

A surge in the demand for ethanol -- touted as a greener alternative to gasoline -- could have a serious environmental downside for the Chesapeake Bay, because more farmers growing corn could mean more pollution washing off farm fields, a new study warned yesterday. washingtonpost.com

Past greenmesh posts on ethanol

Comments

KenBob · October 15, 2007 3:15 AM

I think it's a mistake as well, although being originally from Iowa, I know farmers back home are luvin' it...$$ (ethanol plants are popping up faster than corn stalks). We'd be better off growing crops more suited for ethanol production than corn. Unfortunately, our politicians are more interested in schmoozing corn-belt votes and pandering to special interests than actually studying the science.

paul kuehnel · October 15, 2007 11:17 AM

You bring up a key point, "actually studying the science"

I am continuously trying to figure out if people are just lazy, politically/financially motivated or what.

At least some farmers are cashing in.

paul kuehnel · October 18, 2007 3:16 PM

from ray...
According to a 2004 Fox News report, "Since 1991, subsidies for large farms have tripled while subsidies for small farms have not increased. Among these large farms are 12 operations run by Fortune 500 companies."

Primary recipients of the federal largesse contained in the Farm Bill are massive corporations--commercial "farmers" whose average income tops $200,000 per year and average net worth is around $2 million.
fredericksburg.com/opinion

Post a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.