![]()
It's tough to be the greatest Yankee of all time when you have to compete against these two.
For the past few days, The Southpaw has tried to find a reason to defend Chris Rose, the host of Fox's pregame show during the World Series.
You see, Rose made a mistake of monumental proportions and we here at The Southpaw can't figure out why.
Maybe Rose got caught up in the moment.
Maybe a producer fed him the line and he didn't think about it before speaking aloud.
Maybe he was dropped down a flight of stairs at birth.
Even if all three of those things happened, there's no excuse for what he asked during the Game 5 telecast: Is Derek Jeter the greatest Yankee of all time?
Even if Rose hadn't heard of Lou Gehrig or Joe DiMaggio, the question still wasn't defensible.
He has to have heard of Babe Ruth. Right? Otherwise, would he be qualified to even be on the set?
Asking the Jeter question is like asking if the Earth rotates around Venus.
So, this Top 10 list is dedicated to Chris Rose.
It is the 10 greatest Yankees of all time.
Andy Pettitte won the clinching games in each of the Yankees 2009 playoff series, while people debated his legacy.
Here's his legacy:
While he has a high ERA -3.92 - he's been the guy the team has been able to turn to whenever it need's big wins.
It's worth pointing out that during the 2004 collapse against the Red Sox, Pettitte was a member of the Houston Astros.
As a Yankee, he was the MVP of the 2001 ALCS, twice won 20 games, won the clinching game of the 1998 World Series and started the clinchers in 1996 and 2000.
So, yeah, he's been the backbone of five World Champions and that definitely earns him a spot on this list.
![]()
Whether to put Jeter or Jackson here was a hard decision. Jeter has spent his entire career in New York, while Jackson was a hired gun. But there might not have been a better hired gun in Yankees' history. In the 11 seasons before Jackson's arrival, the Yankees made it to the playoffs once. in the 13 seasons after he left, the Yankees did not return to the post season.
During Jackson's five seasons there, the Yankees won two World Series, three pennants and four division titles.
During World Series play as a Yankee, Mr. October batted .400 with eight home runs and 17 RBI.
The franchise' all-time leader in hits, Jeter has collected five rings during his career and been one of the best clutch players ever, with a career .313 average in post season play to go along with 20 home runs.
Whitey Ford was not OJ SImpson's getaway car. And if you don't know who he is, you probably don't know what Monument Park is.
Of all the starting pitchers who's careers started after 1920 - so that includes the likes of Pedro Martinez, Roger Clemens, Greg Maddux, Sandy Koufax, Bob Gibson and Steve Carlton - none has a lower ERA or higher winning percentage.
And, let it be known that while the teams Ford played for were good, his career winning percentage (.690) is higher than those squads, which won at a .576 clip on games he did not pitch.
It could be argued that Mantle had the greatest talent of any player to play in The Bronx.
He had speed. His muscles had muscles. He might have been the greatest combination of speed and power in history. Yes, maybe even better than Barry Bonds.
Mantle was everything a boy in the 1950s dreamed of being.
However, injuries and a drinking problem kept him from reaching the Top 5.
But can you complain when you're the sixth best Yankee of all-time?
It's hard for a Yankee legend to be unappreciated. But we tend to think of Berra as a folksy quote machine.
He was so much more.
Berra didn't win 10 World Series rings because he was a teammate of great players.
He was a defensive wizard behind the plate, batted .285 for his career and blasted more than 300 home runs.
He won three straight MVP awards and baseball historian Bill James lists him as the greatest catcher of all time.
Just for fun, here's a great Berra stat. In 1950, Berra drove in 124 runs on the strength of 28 home runs, a .322 average and a .915 OPS. All the while, he struck out just 12 times.
![]()
There are closers and there is Mariano Rivera.
Scoring one run off the man with 526 saves is like swimming the English Channel. It can be done, just not often.
Scoring two runs off the man with a 0.74 post-season ERA is like putting hair spray back in the aerosol bottle.
Scoring three runs of the man with eight seasons of an ERA below 2.00 is like finding the end of the rainbow.
Even Yankee haters have to love the Iron Horse.
And it's not because of his tragic ending. Gehrig is the Yankee who played alongside Ruth and forced pitchers to pitch to him.
Consider this: In 1927, Gehrig drove in a record 175 runs. But that was the same season Ruth blasted 60 home runs. So that means at least 60 times during that season Gehrig came to the plate with nobody on base. And he still set the record.
Let's get one thing straight. If Joe DiMaggio doesn't spend three of his prime years in the service of his country, Jeter is still chasing the Clipper's franchise hits record.
DiMaggio was America's idol. He has that famous hitting streak record. He had more home runs than strikeouts. He batted .325. And he played center field with uncommon grace.
Oh, and he married Marilyn Monroe.
If Ruth is the mythical Yankee. Joltin' Joe is the iconic Yankee.
Babe Ruth was supposed to go into the priesthood. Instead, he became a god.
If Ruth doesn't go to the Yankees, the franchise never comes close to the beast that it is.
Let's just do a quick run down of some of Ruth's not-so-well-known accomplishments in pinstripes:
- He led the league in runs seven times. Rickey Henderson, for his career, did so five times.
- He smashed 107 triples. Alex Rodriguez and Jeter have combined for 85 three-baggers.
- Ruth had eight seasons of 130 or more runs batted in. Rodriguez and Barry Bonds have combined for six.
Of course, Ruth was the first player to hit 30, 40, 50 and 60 home runs in a season and 300, 400, 500, 600 and 700 for a career.
He also had a .342 career batting average. That's 25 points higher than Derek Jeter's career mark.
He's the reason there was a Yankee Stadium, that players wear uniform numbers, that foul poles exist and that an athlete can make more money than the president.


Great column, Mr. Abdalla.
e.
I cant argue with anything you have there. Although are we talking about Post-season or all time. I was born in 1975 so you will understand my selection of Donny Baseball. He carried that team for years with less than stellar pitching, not including Guidry, who was in his twilight. (Lee Gutterman was our ace and he was a closer. Kevin plunk and Andy Hawkins were blockbuster deals)
How about The Gator....his '78 season of 25 wins and 1.74 ERA were paramount to the World Series run.
and as an after thought, and people will think I'm nuts, but it wasn't Wetland in 96, but Jimmy Leyritz who came up big to change and win that series.
Sorry it took a while to respond.
The three players that just missed the cut were, in order, Red Ruffing, Mattingly and Roger Maris.
This was for their overall performance. If it was for just postseason, Jeter would probably top the list and be followed by the others.
I had a hard time putting Mattingly on here because, for the Yankees (and you hear this incessantly from their fans) the only thing that matters is championships and Mattingly never won one.
But you can't deny he was a very, very good ballplayer.
That said, I've always believed if he and Kirby Puckett - two very good, complete players - had switched teams, Mattingly would have played in relative obscurity and Puckett would be the most beloved Yankee other than Ruth, DiMaggio and Gehrig.
Mattingly average 210 hits, 30 homers, 121 runs batted in and .337 from 1984-1987. However, from there on, his career averages were 154, 12, 73 and .292.
That's an eight year run comparable to Mark Grace's numbers, but probably not as good as the Cubs' first baseman, who hit 20 points higher during his prime and reliably played in 150 games a season with no offensive production around him.
Guidry was a tough guy to leave off too because he had five Cooperstown-worthy seasons and was clutch in the playoffs.
However, he'd probably be No. 15 on the list, behind Lefty Gomez, who's in the Hall of Fame.